So indulge me if you will - I need to rant.
Tonight I received an e-mail from the parent of one of my students (a rather good student - I was kind of surprised) telling me that her daughter would not be at our competition tomorrow (this was barely 24 hours before we are competing!) because she was going out of town to see some family. To give you some background to understand the situation: at the beginning of the season (like 4 months ago) I gave them a schedule with all of our competitions. At that time, I also discussed our contract with them that contains all my rules and expectations. Then they took a copy of that contract home for their parents to read and for both of them to sign stating that they agreed to follow those rules. This is required for anyone who wants to participate. Well... in that contract it lays out a VERY detailed attendance policy which states, among other things, that they are not allowed to miss any competitions. The only way they could get approved to miss a competition is because they are in the hospital dying or a family member is dying. This is, obviously because their absence does not effect only themselves. They are a part of the team and are all dependant on each other. The rest of the team is hurt if they are gone. The contract goes on to further state that if they miss a performance for any reason other than an extreme emergency - they will receive a failing grade for the course.
So, this parent telling me all of a sudden that her daughter won't be competing TOMORROW for a not even remotely okay reason and then also saying that she hopes the consequences won't be too severe is CRAZY! Absolutely freaking ridiculous! And totally unacceptable!!! Why would that be okay? How are kids supposed to learn to make and KEEP commitments??? How are kids ever supposed to learn that our choices have consequences if their parents are constantly trying to shield them from the consequences of their actions and teaching them that they are the exception to the rule????
HELLO PEOPLE!!!
What kind of a world are we creating for ourselves? And for our children?
Parents aren't doing their kids any favors by doing things like that. They need to learn those lessons now. What are they going to do when they grow up and get out into the real world? Are they going to call up their parents and have their parents come down to their college and whine to their professors to change their grade? (I've dealt with that too. Another nightmare. Last term. Grrrr..... I had to change a girl's grade who should have already been at an F, but I graciously gave her a C+ and then I had to change her grade to a B+. Grrrrrrr...... Everlasting bitterness and rage!)
Grrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr........ Its times like this that make me question why I am a teacher. I love it normally. But instances like this are SO frustrating.
Anyways, I read a quote today that I think is most excellent and very appropriate for this situation. I wish I had saved it. Basically it just said that when we try and shield others from the consequences of their actions we create a world full of fools. Below, I will put a few more quotes. I invite you to ponder and to make a pledge that you will not be one of those stupid parents.
"Accept responsibility for your life. Know that it is you who will get you where you want to go, no one else." - Les Brown
"Hold yourself responsible for a higher standard than anybody else expects of you, never excuse yourself. " Henry Ward Beecher
"Man must cease attributing his problems to his environment, and learn again to exercise his will - his personal responsibility. " Albert Schweitzer
"In each action we must look beyond the action at our past, present, and future state, and at others whom it affects, and see the relations of all those things. And then we shall be very cautious." Blaise Pascal (Pensées)
"It is easy to dodge our responsibilities, but we cannot dodge the consequences of dodging our responsibilities." Josiah Stamp
Glow Stick Baby
2 days ago
7 comments:
here here briana!! this was one of my biggest pet peeves when i was student teaching--parents who make excuses for their kids and expect teachers to do WHATEVER the parents say. i ran into this quite a few times and each time i was shocked that the parent actually thought they were doing what was best for the kid. one girl i taught had a slight learning disability, and so her mom constantly told me that i needed to excuse her from assignments, even though she was completely capable of completing the assignments. really, what are you teaching your children? that all that matters are grades, and not learning. sooo ridiculous. good luck with your situation. i would totally fail the girl if i were you. if i've learned one thing in my life, it's that you can't let people walk all over you. once they know that you're serious, they'll stop trying.
anyway, good luck!
You need to stand firm baby, make an example out of her ands the situation. I know we wern't as good as we should have been with you kids and we are worse with Dallin and Channi than we were with you and Samantha. I am going to pledge to do better. I'm running into that kind of thing at work and it is really frustrating... hey by the way give your mom a call. could ya?
Stick to your guns sweetie, if you let her off you're not being fair to her or the other girls on the team.
I know you'll make the right choice
I love you gobs,
mom
Grrrrrr.....
Even my blood was boiling. "Enabling" bad or irresponsible behavior is a terrible mistake. Parents that enable their children will probably realize their mistake when they are eighty and they are bailing out their adult children from some financial or emotional disaster YET AGAIN!!! It really bugs!
I hear ya! I would be just as ticked off as you are! My clients are BEYOND ridiculous about commitments. They have to cancel 24 hours in advance to not get charged, and yet they'll no-show their appointment and get angry when you charge them for FORGETTING their appointment! You just have to be tough! Otherwise you get angry and resentful! I'm a big believer in tough love, if you hold them responsible they will learn their lesson and untimately respect you. If not, then they'll learn eventually...
Amy: yeah its hard - sometimes people think the world revolves around them.... they forget that even though they forgot to come - you were still planning on it and were there.... argh.... silly people
I agree with all you're saying, but as a parent I know that sometimes the line between enabling and being your child's advocate, can be pretty blurry. I believe that kids need to be held accountable. I also believe that they need to have parents who believe in them and trust them, who will be their champions. I also believe that most teachers are wonderful people trying to do their very best, and that they are usually right. The level of disrespect I see in the schools is disturbing. But still--teachers are not perfect, and even if they're nearly perfect, they have bad days. So I always wanted to give my child a fair hearing before I jumped to conclusions. And there was a time or two when I felt the teacher was out of bounds and intervened. (Your husband being forced to stand in front of the class and apologize for losing his snake comes to mind. I'm not real big on public humiliation, and let's be honest, he was probably the only person who cared about the snake in the first place. And it was his snake! Oh--did I mention that she told him he had to stay outside until he found the snake?!)
Anyway, definitely understand your frustration.
Eric has told me about the snake story. So sad. That was definitely a time to intervene!!
Post a Comment